When Is a Cult Not a Cult? Understanding Coercive Control in Australian Groups

The term "cult" often evokes images of secluded communities with outlandish beliefs, but the reality is far more complex. According to Renee's Cult Ranking System, a key characteristic of a cult is coercive control—a form of manipulation that traps individuals in the group by undermining their ability to make autonomous decisions. In Australia, several groups that might not seem like cults on the surface exhibit these controlling behaviours, while others manage to fly under the radar despite fitting the criteria.

What Is Coercive Control?

Coercive control, as outlined by Renee’s system, involves a pattern of behaviour that intimidates, degrades, isolates, and controls a person. This form of psychological abuse is designed to make the victim dependent on the abuser for all aspects of their life. Within the context of a cult, coercive control manifests through tactics like emotional manipulation, financial exploitation, restricted access to information, and strict rules that limit personal freedom.

Hidden Cults in Plain Sight

Many groups in Australia operate under the guise of legitimate organisations but employ coercive control tactics. For example:

1. The Universal Medicine Group - Presenting itself as a health and wellness organisation, Universal Medicine has faced allegations of coercive control, with former members describing manipulative practices and extreme lifestyle demands imposed by the leadership.

2. The Twelve Tribes - A religious community that appears to offer a supportive, communal living environment, but former members have reported a high level of control over personal lives, strict discipline, and isolation from the outside world.

3. Kenja Communication - Marketed as a personal development and communication training organisation, Kenja Communication has been accused of manipulating members and exerting undue influence over their lives, including financial exploitation and emotional control.

Cults That Fly Under the Radar

Some groups are even more insidious, maintaining a low profile while exerting high levels of coercive control. These include:

1. The Order of St Charbel - Operating under a religious guise, this group has been reported to enforce strict, controlling rules on its members, including arranged marriages and restricted contact with the outside world.

2. The House of Prayer for All Nations - This group presents itself as a charismatic Christian organisation but has been accused of isolating members, controlling their finances, and using fear-based tactics to maintain control.

3. The Jesus Christians - A small, nomadic group that 'encourages" members to donate a kidney to a stranger as a demonstration of faith, which critics argue is a form of coercive control that exploits vulnerable individuals.

Recognising the Signs

Identifying a cult is not always straightforward, especially when the group appears benign or even beneficial. However, Renee’s Cult Ranking System provides clear criteria for recognising coercive control:

• Isolation: Restricting members' contact with outsiders and limiting access to external information.

• Manipulation: Using guilt, fear, and pressure to control behaviour and thoughts.

• Exploitation: Financial, emotional, or physical exploitation of members.

• Absolute Authority: Leaders who demand unquestioning loyalty and obedience.

By understanding these signs, we can better identify and protect against coercive control, whether it occurs in high-profile organisations or those flying under the radar.

Summing Up When Is a Cult Not a Cult

When is a cult not a cult? The answer lies in the presence of coercive control. Groups that manipulate and dominate their members, regardless of how they present themselves, fit the definition of a cult according to Renee's Cult Ranking System. By shedding light on these tactics and examining specific Australian examples, we can raise awareness and safeguard individuals from becoming victims of coercive control.

For more information on cults and how to recover from coercive control, visit Recover from Coercive Control.